Shower vs Tub: What Buyers Want - Rhode Island Homes
When selling a home in Rhode Island, every renovation decision matters. Few choices spark more debate among homeowners than the bathroom question: should you keep that bathtub or convert to a walk-in shower? The answer depends on your home's location, your target buyer, and current real estate trends across the Ocean State.
Rhode Island buyers have distinct preferences shaped by our unique mix of historic homes, coastal properties, and modern developments. Understanding what buyers want in Providence, Warwick, Cranston, and Newport can help you make the right call for your property.
What Rhode Island Home Buyers Prefer
The shower versus tub debate has shifted significantly over the past decade. Nationally, walk-in showers have gained tremendous popularity, but Rhode Island presents some interesting local variations worth understanding.
First-time home buyers in Rhode Island, particularly those shopping in Pawtucket, Central Falls, and Woonsocket, often prioritize move-in ready bathrooms with modern fixtures. These buyers typically prefer updated showers with glass enclosures over dated tub and shower combinations. They want low maintenance and contemporary aesthetics without planning immediate renovations.
Meanwhile, families searching for homes in East Greenwich, Barrington, and Cumberland have different priorities. These buyers frequently want at least one bathtub in the home for bathing young children. A house with zero bathtubs can actually hurt your sale price in family-oriented Rhode Island communities.
Empty nesters and retirees looking in Narragansett, Westerly, and South Kingstown often prefer walk-in showers for accessibility and safety reasons. This demographic values curbless shower designs, grab bars, and built-in seating that allows aging in place.
Providence Bathroom Renovation
Providence home buyers encounter everything from Victorian mansions on the East Side to modern condos in the Jewelry District. The city's diverse housing stock means bathroom preferences vary significantly by neighborhood.
In College Hill and Blackstone, buyers expect a certain level of historic charm. Completely removing a clawfoot tub from a turn-of-the-century home can actually decrease value. These buyers often appreciate restored original fixtures alongside modern conveniences. The ideal setup in these neighborhoods typically includes a primary bathroom with a spacious shower and a secondary bathroom retaining classic tub elements.
Downtown Providence condos and lofts tell a different story. Buyers shopping for urban living spaces generally prefer sleek, modern showers with frameless glass. Space comes at a premium in these properties, and a well-designed walk-in shower makes small bathrooms feel larger and more luxurious.
Federal Hill and the West End attract a mix of young professionals and growing families. Homes in these neighborhoods benefit from versatile bathroom configurations. Keeping one full bathroom with a tub while converting another to a shower-only design often appeals to the broadest range of Providence buyers.
Warwick and Cranston Buyer Expectations
Warwick and Cranston represent Rhode Island's suburban heart. These cities attract families, commuters, and buyers seeking more space for their money compared to Providence or the coastal communities.
Most Warwick home buyers expect at least one bathtub, particularly in three-bedroom or larger homes. The city's family-friendly reputation means parents shopping for homes in Apponaug, Oakland Beach, or Conimicut assume they will have tub access for young children. Removing the only bathtub from a Warwick family home is generally a mistake.
Cranston buyers show similar preferences, especially in neighborhoods like Garden City, Edgewood, and Western Cranston. However, updated primary bathrooms with walk-in showers consistently attract positive attention during showings. The winning formula for most Cranston homes includes a modern shower in the primary bathroom plus a tub and shower combination in the secondary bathroom.
Key features Warwick and Cranston buyers want include:
- Walk-in showers with built-in niches for toiletries
- Tub and shower combinations in family bathrooms
- Updated tile work in neutral colors
- Good water pressure and modern fixtures
- Adequate bathroom ventilation and lighting
Newport and Coastal Rhode Island Preferences
Newport real estate operates in its own category. Buyers shopping for homes in Newport, Middletown, and Portsmouth often have higher budgets and specific expectations for luxury finishes.
Historic Newport homes present unique challenges. Many properties in the Point neighborhood, Historic Hill, and along Bellevue Avenue feature original bathrooms that contribute to overall historic value. Buyers interested in these homes often want period-appropriate fixtures, which can include restored clawfoot tubs or antique pedestal sinks.
Waterfront properties and newer construction in Newport typically command spa-like bathroom designs. Walk-in showers with multiple shower heads, rainfall fixtures, and high-end tile work appeal to luxury buyers. These bathrooms often include separate soaking tubs as standalone features rather than traditional tub and shower combinations.
Coastal buyers in Narragansett, South Kingstown, and Westerly frequently want outdoor shower access for rinsing off after beach days. This regional preference means some buyers care less about indoor tub options when a property includes a well-designed outdoor shower.
How Bathroom Choices Affect Rhode Island Home Values
Real estate data consistently shows that bathroom updates provide strong returns on investment. However, the type of update matters significantly for Rhode Island sellers.
A complete bathroom renovation in Rhode Island typically costs between $15,000 and $35,000 depending on scope and finishes. Converting a tub to a walk-in shower as part of a larger renovation generally adds value when done thoughtfully and in appropriate contexts.
Removing the only bathtub from a Rhode Island home can reduce your buyer pool by 20 to 30 percent according to local real estate professionals. Families with young children often eliminate tub-free homes from consideration immediately. This reduction in interested buyers can translate to longer time on market and potentially lower offers.
The safest approach for most Rhode Island homes involves maintaining at least one bathtub while updating other bathrooms with modern shower designs. This strategy keeps your home competitive with family buyers while also appealing to buyers who prefer showers.
Factors that influence bathroom renovation ROI in Rhode Island:
- Home price point and target buyer demographic
- Number of bathrooms in the property
- Neighborhood expectations and comparable homes
- Quality of materials and installation
- Overall home condition and other updates needed
Best Shower Designs for Rhode Island Homes
When Rhode Island homeowners do choose walk-in showers, certain designs perform better than others in our local market. Understanding these preferences helps ensure your renovation appeals to buyers.
Frameless glass enclosures remain popular across Rhode Island. These designs make bathrooms appear larger and more modern while providing easy cleaning and a high-end aesthetic. Buyers in Providence, Warwick, Newport, and most other Rhode Island communities respond positively to frameless glass.
Curbless or zero-threshold showers have gained significant traction, particularly in communities with older populations. These designs offer accessibility benefits while also creating a sleek, contemporary look. Westerly, Narragansett, and East Greenwich buyers often appreciate curbless shower options.
Tile choices matter considerably for Rhode Island bathrooms. Large format tiles in neutral colors currently dominate local preferences. Subway tiles remain popular for a classic look, while buyers increasingly appreciate textured or patterned accent tiles used sparingly.
Built-in shower niches and benches add functionality that Rhode Island buyers notice and value. These features suggest thoughtful design and eliminate the need for hanging caddies or freestanding accessories.
When to Keep the Bathtub in Your Rhode Island Home
Despite the popularity of walk-in showers, bathtubs remain essential in many Rhode Island home sales. Knowing when to preserve or install a tub helps maximize your property's appeal.
Homes with only one full bathroom should almost always keep the bathtub. Single-bathroom homes in Pawtucket, Central Falls, Providence, and other Rhode Island communities need tub access to remain competitive with family buyers and achieve full market value.
Properties in family-oriented neighborhoods benefit from tub and shower combinations. Cranston, Warwick, Cumberland, Lincoln, and North Kingstown all attract significant numbers of buyers with young children who require bathing facilities.
Historic homes often lose character when original bathtubs are removed. Clawfoot tubs in Providence, Newport, and Bristol properties can become selling features rather than obstacles when properly restored and presented.
Situations where keeping the tub makes sense:
- Only one full bathroom in the home
- Family-oriented neighborhood with young parent buyers
- Historic home with original period fixtures
- Adequate bathroom space without feeling cramped
- Selling in a competitive market where broad appeal matters
Rhode Island Bathroom Renovation Tips for Sellers
Making smart bathroom decisions before listing your Rhode Island home can significantly impact your sale timeline and final price. Local market knowledge guides these choices.
Start by researching comparable homes in your specific Rhode Island community. Look at recently sold properties in your neighborhood to understand bathroom configurations that succeeded. Pay attention to days on market and final sale prices relative to listing prices.
Consider your home's target buyer when planning bathroom updates. A three-bedroom Colonial in Barrington will likely sell to a different buyer than a two-bedroom condo in Providence. Understanding your most likely buyer helps guide shower versus tub decisions.
Quality matters more than quantity for Rhode Island bathroom renovations. One beautifully updated bathroom often provides better returns than two mediocre updates. Focus your budget on high-impact changes like new vanities, updated lighting, modern mirrors, and fresh tile work.
Neutral design choices appeal to the broadest range of Rhode Island buyers. While bold colors and trendy patterns might suit your taste, gray, white, and beige tones help buyers envision themselves in the space. Save personality for easily changed items like towels and accessories.
Making the Right Choice for Your Rhode Island Property
The shower versus tub question has no universal answer for Rhode Island homes. Your specific property, location, and target buyer should guide this important decision.
Most Rhode Island homeowners selling in 2025 should maintain at least one bathtub while considering shower updates for additional bathrooms. This balanced approach captures family buyers while also appealing to those who prefer modern shower designs.
Providence, Warwick, Cranston, and other Rhode Island communities each have unique characteristics that influence buyer expectations. Researching your local market and understanding neighborhood preferences ensures your bathroom decisions support rather than hinder your sale.
Whether you choose to update your shower, keep your bathtub, or find a creative solution that includes both, making informed decisions based on Rhode Island buyer preferences positions your home for success. The right bathroom configuration can reduce time on market, attract stronger offers, and help you achieve your selling goals in the competitive Rhode Island real estate market.











